Skip to main content

Maude Muto - Blog Post #2 - Stop it Already - How Social Media Monetization Repels Viewers.


I have become all too aware of how internet searches and website cookies are tracking and capturing data from my use. For example, I recently searched for tall boots with narrow calves, and immediately, all of my social media feeds were saturated with ads for boots. All the ads I see are driven by data monetization, which gathers information based on user preferences and website history and sells it to third parties.

Data-driven advertising targeting that Facebook embeds into my feed is distracting and not useful. I X out every ad that I come across, hoping that it will not reappear. Do you do the same? However, doing so makes me wonder if closing the ad captures my behavior as a positive interaction, much in the same way that when one clicks out of a pop-up ad, "no" often means "yes."

As we know, Facebook mainly consists of older users; perhaps these users are unaware that they can click to close an ad or change their privacy settings. I have noticed that many of my Facebook "friends" keep sharing the same advice on how to get more content from people they know, and less from companies trying to sell something. Here is one example:

If you are thinking of getting off FB because of the volume of sales ads and trash stuff, hold your finger anywhere in this post and click ′copy'. Go to your page where it says 'What's on your mind?' Tap your finger anywhere in the blank field. Click paste. This upgrades the system. Goodbye, annoying ads, and hello new and old friends!

I warn them to use Snopes to look up the statement that they posted to determine its truthfulness.
Younger audiences who visit Instagram and TikTok are savvier than most Facebook users. However, they are easily swayed by influencers. My college-aged daughter recently got her eyebrows laminated after admitting to viewing many influencers' posts featuring images of their "perfect" eyebrows. The influencers are earning money through brand deals and partnerships. However, as Dr. Ying Sun mentions in this week's lecture, influencer posts can "blur the line between authentic content and advertising" (Sun, 2025, 6:36).


Do you pay for YouTube or LinkedIn premium subscriptions? Although I find YouTube ads distracting, I understand and accept that this is how much content creators earn revenue through participating in AdSense. If I were actively pursuing a new job, I might consider buying a premium LinkedIn subscription, though I feel that the platform is suited to careers that rely on heavy networking, such as sales.

Information professionals, including middle and high school teachers, should teach digital literacy as it relates to the monetization of social media. Users should be aware of the methods that social media platforms use to entice and persuade viewers. Has your library considered offering a program on social media?

Reference

Sun, Y. (n.d.). Social Media Audience and Platforms: Who is Using What and Why it Matters. LIS 558 OA1: Social Media. https://ublearns.buffalo.edu/d2l/le/content/319934/viewContent/5030600/View



Comments

  1. Hi Maude, thank you for a terrific take on such a new topic of navigation for us librarians in a social media oriented, and now data-driven advertising interactions! A someone who has similarly seen posts on facebook of an actual post exclaiming their attempt at privacy terms, I've always wondered how this type of information process and cycle worked as a parallel dissemination process. I think your point on teaching digital literacy as it relates to the monetization of social media, a very real chapter to the book of our use of it, is incredibly essential to the work, and to ours. Great share!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Maude, I think library programming centered around social media would be an excellent idea! I could see librarians hosting workshops on the positives: how to improve your social media presence and get the most out of each platform, and the negatives: how to protect your data privacy and navigate ads and other distracting monetized content.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Kristen Strmel Blog Post #1 - Teens and Twitter: The Right to Risk?

Let me start with what I imagine is a pretty radical opinion: I don’t think anyone below 18 should be allowed to access Twitter. Turns out quite a few people agree with me , albeit to varying extents. Now, I’m not married to this opinion, but I used to be on Twitter (or X–I’m calling it Twitter for posterity’s sake) a ton. While it was a fantastic site for sharing art, quick access to news, and memes, the amount of vitriol and toxicity that could permeate into previously safe spaces made me genuinely worry for the mental health of teens whose brains are still developing. I mean, you don't know if the person you’re arguing with is 13 or 30. You also don’t know how far the person you’re arguing with is willing to go to defend their opinion–they might be content to just drop the beef, or they might come crawling into your private messages to threaten you. Or they might share a screenshot of your conversation in an attempt to publicly shame you. Not exactly the type of thing I imagine ...

Madeline Feehan Blog Post #1: #TRENDING: Using TikTok Trends to Promote Your Library!

#TRENDING: Using TikTok Trends to Promote Your Library! By Madeline Feehan Be honest: how many hours do you spend on TikTok? We're all adults and professionals here, so we won't judge. I'll be honest: I spend too many. It's not necessarily my fault. TikTok is designed to be addictive according to studies like this one from Brown University:  What Makes TikTok so Addictive?: An Analysis of the Mechanisms Underlying the World’s Latest Social Media Craze , and although TikTok has an age restriction of 13+, kids much younger are using it daily. Between the short length of videos (typically a minute or under, the most common is 30 seconds), the endless for you page, the like button, and the effortless scrolling, you can waste hours on TikTok without even realizing it. What if I told you that you could spin the addictive nature of TikTok into a good thing? We like TikTok because it makes us laugh. We enjoy how it has trends that are easy to follow, and anyone can be a creator...

Is Less More with Instagram Posts?

An interesting thing happened a couple of months ago at the East Hampton Library : both the young adult and children’s departments posted on Instagram on the same day. The topics and content were completely unrelated, but we were told that we should never post on the same day again. What was interesting about it was that this was the first time the department heads had been guided on social media. The reason given was that too many posts would leave viewers uninterested and cause them to ignore our content.   Once we all heard that we should never post on the same day, it got me thinking: who is coordinating the content, what schedule are we following, do we have a marketing plan, should we have brand consistency with specified fonts, colors, and logos throughout? And is it true that multiple posts would have an adverse reaction? As I started scrolling through the library’s feed, what jumped out to me was that the topics were mostly about upcoming events, with young adult and child...