Skip to main content

Maude Muto - Blog Post #3 - Social Media of Public Libraries – It's Not all Fun & Games


Has your public library fully embraced the use of social media? I know mine is trying, but there is no point person or marketing department for librarians to consult. It seems like department members are creating posts without much planning or foresight. Therefore, the platforms that we use and the content posted need deep thought and analysis.

As Kietzmann et al. (2011) explain, libraries should follow a social media framework that includes “seven functional building blocks: identity, conversations, sharing, presence, relationships, reputations, and groups” (p. 241). We need to start meeting together and questioning whether or not our library adheres to, or even considers, any of the aforementioned building blocks.

Scrolling through the East Hampton Library’s Instagram feed one can quickly notice that the majority of the content is about the children and young adult departments. There is no sense of identity that is obvious, no logos present, and no consistent tone of language used. Conversations and sharing is limited, while presence is not applicable to the platform. Relationships of followers is not apparent; reputation seems insignificant; and groups are not available within the Instagram platform.

The East Hampton Library would benefit from following Kietzmann et al.’s (2011) four guidelines: “cognize, congruity, curate, and chase” (p. 249). To cognize, the library needs to take stock of metrics and reporting provided by both Instagram and Facebook. Questions to ask include: are we reaching who we want to market to, is the number of followers and shares increasing? One thing we can do better is to include more interactive content and reduce the number of repeated posts across both platforms.

Congruity refers to the requirement for the East Hampton Library to “develop strategies that are congruent with, or suited to, different social media functionalities and the goals” of the library (Kietzmann et al., 2011, p. 249). Unfortunately, the East Hampton Library has no strategy or marketing plan and no one is discussing which platform we should use for which audience and type of content. Hence, we need to curate our social media content and consider when and if the library should respond to viewer’s comments. Analyzing social media platform reports and metrics can lead the library to evaluate the chase for upcoming messages and posts. See? It’s not all fun and games when it comes to social media. A lot of planning and thought needs to go into it.

References

Kietzmann, J. H., Hermkens, K., McCarthy, I. P., & Silvestre, B. S. (2011). Social media? Get serious! Understanding the functional building blocks of social media. Business Horizons, 54(3), 241–251.

Comments

  1. Hi Maude, thank you for a very intentional and relevant post this week! So much to agree with here - without a formalized social media strategy, there is no "four guidelines: “cognize, congruity, curate, and chase” (p. 249). I wonder if libraries could create more formal social media policies that focused on not just which platforms to use and not use and privacy, but the intentionality and "business" strategy or formal evaluation and/or assessment as it pertains to the experience of both posting on behalf of a library, and interacting with the reponse of those posts. Very helpful post this week, thanks for the share!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think a great place for libraries to start is to look at the American Library Association's Social Media Guidelines https://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/socialmediaguidelines. But all library staff need to be given time to read this, learn, develop policy, create a marketing calendar, and appoint someone to post social media content.

      Delete
  2. Hi Maude, thanks for this post! I couldn't agree more that finding a brand, being consistent, and posting with intention are all key to running a successful social media page. If some of those ingredients are missing, that can make the social media presence suffer. A big one you point out is the lack of logos or consistent language. That can hurt your library, so I'd suggest using resources like Canva to try to revive the account and come up with a more consistent theme. For example, since Instagram's format is typically that you see three posts in a row, maybe you could group some things together by topic- have a row about children's programming with a video to the left, an infographic with text in the middle, a picture on the right and then alternate and switch to another department with the same format for the next row. It could be very difficult to start this process, but luckily this class will help us and I'm sure you'll find valuable resources :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Rachel Robertazzi9/23/2025 09:24:00 AM

    Hi Maude!

    Totally agree; without a strategy or consistent tone, library social media can feel like the Wild West. Looking at metrics would be a good first step to see what’s actually working and provide a concrete plan to move forward with.

    I love your point about interactive content; that would make the library’s social media feel more like a conversation instead of just a one-way announcement. Having someone to coordinate posts (or at least planning meetings) would probably help a lot. It's more work than it looks!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Maude Muto Blog Post #10 - Library Advocacy through Social Media

Yes, we all know that social media is essential for informing patrons about programs, services, and resources, but how many of you also use social media for library advocacy? Community stakeholders can work as partners to promote all the free and wonderful things that your library has to offer.   According to the American Library Association , “advocacy is central to everything we do, from intellectual freedom to library funding (ALA.org). The ALA recommends several ways to achieve library advocacy. One suggestion is for librarians to report instances of censorship of patron-challenged books. As ALA gathers data, it can help libraries combat censorship. Another way to support a public library is to invite a congressperson to tour the library and learn about all that it offers. With the politician’s advance authorization, the library may be able to tag them in the library post and ask them to share information about their library tour. One of my relatives just won her second term as...

Madeline Feehan Blog Post #7: Jet2Holiday- Embrace the Chaos!

A TikTok example of the viral "nothingbeatsajet2holiday" meme format   an example of how the viral meme is becoming merch   Blog Post #7: Embrace the Chaos! By Madeline Feehan What do you do when your organization goes viral for the wrong reasons? Do you: A) Panic B) Rebrand C) Sweep it under the rug and pretend it never happened D) Face it head-on and embrace the chaos I'd recommend option D because it's a great way to take accountability while also being transparent. If you can recognize your flaws and play off them, it's a much more mature and respectable reaction than simply tuning them out and making yourselves look better. This same subject came up in Kristen's blog post about the Coldplay concert incident . She asked us if we thought it would be better if the company the CEO worked at would be better off partnering with Coldplay and giving in to the memes or trying to steer attention away.  This same topic comes up when I think of Jet2 Holidays. Althoug...