Skip to main content

Maude Muto Blog Post #9 - Is That Social Media Post Just CRAAP?

By

 

Librarians are aware of using the CRAAP test (currency, relevance, authority, accuracy, and purpose) when checking websites for authenticity and truthfulness. However, it may be helpful for the layperson to consider these factors when viewing social media posts.

Readers should ask themselves, Is the information current? Is it a recent event? Just yesterday, I came across an Instagram reel on TikTok with images of Hurricane Melissa heading to New York. After careful evaluation, I realized that the image was indeed showing a storm track, but it was of Hurricane Ida from 2021 – certainly not current. The fear-mongering is rampant!

Moving on through the CRAAP test checklist, I then considered whether the post was relevant. Well, it certainly was as Hurricane Melissa had just made landfall on Jamaica. I had been clicking on many images of the hurricane, and the algorithms caught up with me, showing me storm information on every other post. Evaluating the authority of any information starts with considering the source – who wrote, published, or sponsored it (Evaluating Information, 2010). One would need to evaluate the author’s qualifications and expertise on the subject.

The accuracy of the post also needs to be taken into consideration. Increasingly, people and businesses are utilizing AI to generate content for their social media platforms. The resulting language often includes grammatical and typographic errors. Additionally, viewers need to examine the post for bias, emotion, and tone.

In the CRAAP test, P stands for purpose. Look deeper: is the purpose of the social media post to sell a product, link the viewer to another account, or convince them? Is the post associated with the political party or a religious institution? We must all be diligent when scrolling through socials. How often have you gone down the rabbit hole or doom scrolled? Try to apply all of the aspects of the CRAAP test to evaluate the social media content and credibility.

References

Evaluating Information – Applying the CRAAP Test. California State University Chico. (2010, September 7). https://library.csuchico.edu/sites/default/files/craap-test.pdf

Comments

  1. Anonymous10/31/2025 04:02:00 PM

    Hi Maude! Thank you for this blog post on something so critical to the determination of information accuracy - "Is the purpose of the social media post to sell a product, link the viewer to another account, or convince them?" I think there is so much to unpack in this question, and it makes me wonder about the impact of taking the time to simply ask these series of questions in a reflective manner that was found in the article, " The Psychology of Fake News." Thank you for your share! I wonder what other heuristics could be found in these online information seeking and reposting behaviors.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Madeline Feehan Blog Post #11: Killing Eve and "Bury your Gays" Backlash

By
Image source: The 'Killing Eve' Finale has Infuriated Queer Fans   Blog Post #11: Killing Eve and "Bury Your Gays" Backlash By Madeline Feehan Some of the fiercest allies and supporters of diversity, equity, and inclusion (and some of its greatest opponents) can be found in the unlikeliest of places: Tumblr, Twitter, and AO3. What do these people all have in common? They are heavily immersed in fandoms. Whether they're reblogging content or creating their own, whether they're starting Reddit threads, writing fanfiction, drawing fanart, posting to their stories, making video edits, or starting petitions, these fans all share a passion for fictional worlds. So what happens when a fandom all comes together and agrees on one thing? This is what happened with the Killing Eve fandom after the show's finale. Sometimes audiences are split between opinions. For example, when a beloved book gets turned into a movie, some will argue that the book's better or that...
4 comments
Read more

Kristen Strmel Blog Post #11: #UnwhitewashTheBadBatch: How Social Media Holds Creators Accountable

By
Image source I want to say “It’s always a good day when I can talk about Star Wars,” but that’s not always true. Loving something means acknowledging its flaws, and it’s pretty safe to say that Star Wars as a franchise has a racism problem, from the lack of the BIPOC characters in its movies (and accession to stereotypes when they were depicted), to the racist harassment that that BIPOC actors in recent shows have faced from certain sections of the fandom. While the franchise has taken steps to address these issues in recent years, it’s still got work to do–and if it doesn’t, fans are more than willing to call it out. This exact thing happened in 2021, with the release of The Bad Batch. This show follows a group of clones (soldiers born and bred specifically to fight for the Galactic Republic, introduced in the Prequel Trilogy) known as “The Bad Batch” as they try to find their place in the galaxy during the Empire’s rise. Each member of the The Bad Batch had “desirable mutations” tha...
4 comments
Read more

Madeline Feehan Blog Post #12: AI Books and Libraries

By
Image Source: Nana a Mischevious Monkey by Shum Zay on Amazon Blog Post #12: AI Books and Libraries By Madeline Feehan Is an AI author really an author? Are AI books valid, and should they be on library shelves, or should we steer clear of them? What about  AI- assisted   work? Is the best compromise adding some to our collection and clearly labeling them as AI, or is it best to not even indulge at all?  Do you find work that was written with the help of AI but was also written by a human less egregious than something entirely written by AI? Should those books still be labeled?  These are some of the many fascinating questions discussed by guest speakers who came to my library. Lisa Zuena, Nicole Scherer, and a third librarian from the Nassau County Library Association came in to talk about AI slop and what it means for the future. AI slop refers to poorly edited, weirdly formatted, strangely written books that find their way into ordinary collections. This happens w...
Post a Comment
Read more