Tova Harris - Blog Post #9 - Reddit and Decentralizing Moderation and the potential impact on Teens

 

                                                    (courtesy of Forbes article)

Most teen librarians I know are constantly navigating the evolving digital environments that shape how young people gather, learn, and express themselves. 

One platform they often gravitate toward is Reddit - an open, decentralized forum where users can create or join “subreddits” on virtually any topic imaginable. While this structure promotes community empowerment and diverse dialogue, it also poses serious risks, particularly when it comes to misinformation and hate speech, and particularly the type of hate speech that has come with the current Trump administration and its anti-immigrant policies and social media campaigns.

Unlike centralized platforms that enforce uniform content rules, Reddit relies heavily on volunteer moderators within each subreddit to enforce policies. This means that what is considered unacceptable in one space may be tolerated - or even encouraged - in another.

For teens who are still developing critical thinking skills and media literacy, this uneven enforcement can be confusing, harmful, and overwhelming.

Imagine a scenario where a teen stumbles into a seemingly neutral subreddit discussing immigration policy. Within days, they're exposed to anti-immigrant rhetoric framed as economic facts or cultural concerns - content not explicitly in violation of Reddit’s broad rules but still laced with xenophobic undertones. 

Without strong moderation or clear fact-checking, this rhetoric becomes normalized. Teen users may echo these views at school, at home, or even in their own online posts - believing they’re sharing “truth,” not realizing they've been nudged into ideological echo chambers. Similarly, finding such a subreddit, a teen may send to a fellow teen whose family (or even the teen) is dealing with the very real fear of deportation, establishing a new type of cyber-bullying that is now, in many ways, endorsed and even supported via current news cycles.

In the 2022 report “Youth, Hate Speech, and Online Extremism” by Demos UK and Hope Not Hate, researchers reveal how young people are increasingly exposed to hate speech and extremist content online, often through memes, humor, and seemingly innocuous communities. Rather than seeking out hate, many teens stumble into it passively, on platforms like Reddit, Instagram, or Discord, where racist or anti-immigrant rhetoric is framed as irony or edgy jokes. 

Over time, repeated exposure can normalize harmful views, desensitizing youth to bigotry and increasing the risk of radicalization. The report emphasizes the urgent need for digital literacy education and proactive moderation policies to help young users recognize and reject extremist narratives.

As librarians and educators, we need to prepare youth for these digital spaces by promoting platform literacy, teaching them to ask: Who moderates this space? What are the rules here? What counts as evidence? 

Reddit can be a vibrant learning space - but only if teens are equipped to see the architecture behind the conversation. Decentralization offers freedom - but without guidance, that freedom can lead young users straight into misinformation traps dressed as casual conversation.